CVCA's first graduating class in 1970 had a total of eight graduates. Since then, 2,763 students have graduated from the Academy, with the most recent class of 2007 having 137 students.

Over 95% of CVCA graduates since 1990 have been accepted at colleges and universities in Ohio and the United States.

Numerous CVCA graduates have gone on to lead impressive careers in medicine, law, education, business and other fields. Many alumni are also involved full-time in ministries such as church work, foreign and home missions, Christian schools, and para-church ministries.